Black samurai 😡

Everyone's arguing about whether or not the main character should be black while forgetting the more important point: Ubisoft is trash, and we shouldn't be buying their uninspired shovelware anyway.

The other commenters don't seem to understand the difference between boycotting and gatekeeping...
I'm with you man, I haven't bought any Ubisoft stuff for over 10 years now. And the more I learned the more I got surprised by how shovelware can be made even worse.
- The last Ubisoft game was Assassin’s Creed 3, right?
- So they're boycotting Ubisoft because they're trash and make uninspired shovelware? Do you understand the difference between boycotting and gatekeeping?
I don't understand the gatekeeping here, do you get mad that people enjoy the fast and furious movies? It's not like these are funneling resources away from the tons of great indie games that are literally constantly coming out these days.
- Movies don't demand an unreasonable amount of money and time out of you the viewer, you buy your ticket and watch the film, maybe you buy the DVD, done end of story.
  Ubisoft games demand a minimum of 70 dollars out of you and upwards of 60 hours all while blocking your progress with arbitrary experience checkpoints and pestering you about spending even more money for weapons, gear, mounts, etc. as if it were a free to play MMO like Fortnite, except you already dumped 70 dollars to play the damn thing.
  Not sure where indie games have anything to do with Ubisoft.
- I'm not for gatekeeping but I can understand the pushback in this case. People had the same argument for Bethesda horse armor in the past and it's gradually been abused to stuff like day 1 dlc and Diablo IP becoming a predatory mtx handphone game. At some point if you don't voice concerns over Ubisoft delisting games (the crew) or $100+ pricing bundles, you shouldn't be surprised if Ubi opts to mess with previously beloved IPs for a quick buck.
  It's great that you love indies and all but shaming other people for being frustrated at Ubi's business practices is no better than gatekeeping people for liking their new games.
- you get mad that people enjoy the fast and furious movies
  No, because they are action comedies that consistently deliver.
  Also, I'd be hard pressed to name a more ethnically diverse movie cast. The epitome of a "something for everyone" movie.
Exactly, they are never getting my money.

Wasn't the original premise that you were a dude in the present using a time machine to explore "genetic memory" in a real time simulation in order to find the ark of the covenant or spear of destiny or someshit for the Illuminati?
- Yeah, I think they crammed "becuz aliens" in there a few games later to explain away all the magic.
I was guessing this was about Ghost of Tsushima since it just released on PC. Is his an assassin creed thing?

Technically, they're only "Samurai" if they're produced in Nippon within the duration of the Kamakura Period through the Meiji Restoration. Otherwise they're just sparkling warrior-nobles.

You are thinking of 51% min of corn. And produced in Kentucky. Fuck, thats whiskey. I mean Whisky!
Bourbon, I was talking about bourbon.
- Bourbon doesn't even have to be made in Kentucky, they just can't call it "Kentucky Straight Bourbon" otherwise.

Where was that "historically accurate" crowd when Keanu starred in 47 Ronin?!

Or Jake Gyllenhaal in Prince of Persia. Or Finn Jones as Iron Fist.
Or Ben Affleck as Antonio J. Mendez in Argo, ffs. A role practically made for your Pedro Pascal type actor.
Hell, Tom Cruise pretending to be Irish in Far and Away was awful enough just because of the bad accent.
- Iron fist is a white dude in the source material unlike the other examples.
Oh they were there lol.
Keanu is half Japanese. Tom Cruise as the Last Samurai though...
- Uhm Tom's character was never the last samurai. Did you watch it?
Or about how basically all music you hear when something is set in Asia/the Middle East sounds nothing like real Asian/Middle Eastern music

The argument is always the same. The CHUDS don't want to see black people, women, the gays, etc.

Actually was expecting a Japanese man and woman to choose from.
- There's a playable Japanese woman in parallel to the Black man but I guess women don't count because gAmErS.

i miss the days when people made video games, and they were good.

I'm not sure why people are expecting the character of the video game to make or break the entire video game.

It's a new assassins creed game, it's probably going to be ass, like the rest of them.

animal well.
The medium is alive and well.
- i meant more in regards to these massive studios, of course there are good indie games, there are always good people in any community.

This is some of the worst discourse I’ve seen. I went to the latest Asmongold video about this topic and asked as many people as I could to explain how a black protagonist is pushing an agenda. Not replies. Guess it is hard to explain without claiming “not historically accurate” or just sounding like a white supremacist.

You're working backwards trying to find excuses. Even disregarding the fact that "black guy is meant to be stealthy" is looking objectively wrong, the "I put my hood up and sat on a bench so now I'm invisible" mechanic has been a joke spanning back to literally the first AC game ever made. If you wanted to get upset about how implausible it is, you're more than 15 years too late.
Have you played AC Syndicate? This game is led by the same studio. Going by that game and the official videos on this one, he's not stealthy at all. He's a strong brawler, while the woman is a ninja and you'll get to choose your approach from mission to mission.
If your problem with games is a lack of realism, you must not play very many.
They do something similar in the first Nioh game, but the main character didn't stand out in a world covered in half demons and spirits that all look way weirder than a foreigner with pale skin. Whatever locals they met were mostly dead or fleeing from monsters and the xenophobic culture bits were mostly brushed aside.
That being said I don't think Team Ninja enjoyed the online controversies that happened from making a white guy the main character in Nioh. Nioh 2 went back to having a Japanese half yokai as the lead. I'd wait to see if Ubisoft is capable of making an interesting story out of the foreigner in old Japan premise.
Idc that he's black my issue is that assassin's in ac "blend " into their environment they are "ghosts"
This hasn't been true for a while, except Mirage that tried to do a callback to that. But you know there's also a playable woman who is the perfect ninja archetype? Clad in black and hookchaining over buildings and throwing kunais in people's necks from the shadows or from 10 feet in the air, the type that never actually existed in History.
Probably the same way every AC character has blended into the crowd while wearing radically different clothes from every other person in any given crowd, and those clothes also being extremely overt about the Assassin order membership of the wearer. I mean the assassins robes are color coordinated and adorned with they group logo for god sakes.

I genuinely do not get why people get so angry about the color of a character's skin in a work of historical FICTION. I dgaf about things being historical accurate in my video games. Does the guy look cool? Yup he sure do. Is the game gonna be good? It's Ubisoft so probably not. But let's assume that it will be for arguments sake.

Why is it so important to you that the character not be black? Assassin's creed as a franchise has been around for like what? Almost two decades now? And in all that time we've basically played as only white characters (with some exceptions). I don't see anything wrong with increased representation in works of art or entertainment. The more representation we see in media for any minority group the less likely it will be for the kids that grow up playing these games to grow up as racist assholes. And if you belong to a minority group, seeing someone with your skin tone represented in media will make you less likely to grow up with internalized self loathing. Like you might if all you see in media is the white dude saving the day.

At the end of the day these are works of entertainment. Their purpose isn't historically accuracy. It's entertainment and escapism. If we can't escape racism in a fucking video game how tf are we supposed to prevent it in real life?

Dude, these same folks flipped their shit when the default main character in Crackdown was black, way back in 2007. These idiots don't quit. I mean, we're talking about a game where you're a genetically engineered super-cop and had multiple choices of character race but their fragile egos were shattered because the default choice wasn't the white guy.
It's pathetic.
Mind you, I'm sure they were all fine and nodding their heads when Tom Cruise did the whole white savior thing in The Last Samurai.
- Man that game was so fun.
From the trailer he just seems so terribly out of place. Also, it's bullshit to have a samurai in Japan in a game about assassins when they had fucking ninjas, the Japanese equivalent of assassins.
- The AC games haven't been about covert assassination since Syndicate. They're much more focused on open combat now, and playing a samurai fits that better. Yeah, it's pretty stupid that a game series about assassins isn't really about assassination anymore, but that's where they're at.
- I'd wager there's no accurate historical depiction in any media.
  Everything is stylized or fictionalized to some degree.
  Maybe The Passion of the Christ is closest I can think of as they did all the speech in Aramaic and Old Latin
- He's for players like me who like to hit stuff, not sneak around. There's another stealth main character for people who wanna be sneaky.

I gave up on Far Cry and Watchdogs not because the games were deteriorating with each iteration (they were / are) but because the sexual harrassment ring on which the upper management fed and HR silenced the victims made supporting the company untennable. At least for me.

Since then I've found alternative indie projects that have scratched some of those itches pretty well. I don't play Ubisoft, even those games I already ~~own~~ have licenses for.

I know you're not op but I don't really engage with public gamer forums since gamergate. I don't need the idiotic, racist/sexist/whateverist takes. I just want to forgot about the world for a bit and talk to my friends about how cool the pixels looked at that one point in time. I can get that with my friend on discord.

I thought it was common knowledge that "retainer" was literally the job description of all samurai... but I guess I should have known that the Weaboo Gamergate Brigade would conveniently ignore actual history.

There's a lot of nuance and hair-splitting involved; it's unlikely Yasuke would have been granted the title of samurai, but he was referred to as kosho. He was given a short sword, but not a long sword to pair with it. Samurai were required by law to wear the paired swords, known as daisho, and anyone else was forbidden.
Almost all samurai were indeed retainers, with the exception of ronin. But bushi who were not samurai could still be retainers. It's all kind of a huge classist mess. Thanks feudalism!
If you throw out the hierarchical nonsense, Yasuke fit the role of what most people today would think of as a samurai. It's kind of weird for anyone to argue against that in the fast and loose setting of an Assassin's Creed game. Ubisoft aren't known for churning out painstakingly accurate historical reference works. It's a game with a character roughly based on a distinct historical figure.

Okay, here is what is going on and why people are getting mad. A lot of people are getting sick of the pandering to other cultures that seems way out of place. They just want their games to be games without some political message or propaganda being pushed to them.

This is not the case with this AC game. The person actually exists and Ubisoft loves putting notable historical people in the ACU.

When I see this outrage though I just think of the stink that was caused by Stellar Blade. It was super uncalled for and game media outlets have wild takes on the issue.

All I can say is stay informed and research the issue before seeing a post and getting upset about it. Don’t automatically assume malice or racism (though some people really are) and try to deduce where the anger is coming from.

Okay, here is what is going on and why people are getting mad. A lot of people are getting sick of the pandering to other cultures that seems way out of place. They just want their games to be games without some political message or propaganda being pushed to them.
When gamers complain about this shit, it's usually just dog whistling. These same gamers never complain about the political bias inherent in the call of duty franchise. They're doing the enlightened centrist thing where they pretend to hold a moderate position but are actually deeply reactionary.
This is not the case with this AC game. The person actually exists and Ubisoft loves putting notable historical people in the ACU.
Yeah exactly my point.
Don’t automatically assume malice or racism
Void of logic and reason, I can only assume their position does boil down to malice and racism. Or are you being charitable and assuming ignorance?

Shame, I love the first few AC's ☺️ It was so immersive with good stories. This franchise is dead to me.

Oh no, a black man in a videogame? Your sensibilities must be in shambles.
- No one tell them who's under the mask in Spider Man: Miles Morales.
I'm sure they'll be crying themselves to sleep.
- They never care until stocks plummet and long time fans avoid the game until sales come along. Think the cheapest package will be 70$ while the highest is subscription based.
Because a black person is the main character?
- The bloatware, mtx's and crappy stories

I haven't played any AC games in a long time but why would a game series that's all about playing as stealth assassins have you play as samurai instead of ninjas? Seems like a really big missed opportunity for something like Tenchu

They have strayed far from the original series. It's large open world combat not hidden in the shadows at all now. Even the ninja you play as in this game is operating in the middle of the day in the streets.

I don't think "well the game has magic so it's ok to discard any inconsistencies in plot, world building or historical accuracy" is a good argument. Instead, simply say that it's a relatively minor change that doesn't have that much impact. After all I'm sure there's other historical changes made throughout the franchise other than things required by the plot .

Heck, it would prove that people complaining are doing so because of racism even more since they're not complaining about those changes.

This is literally a historical figure, there's nothing being changed about his race.
- I meant the rank of samurai as the historical inaccuracy, not the characters race.

We already have afro samurai games

Reminds me of...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QNDgOSPCVhQ

I originally watched this video thinking it would be about the old Realism art movement. It wasn't. I watched it anyways