Games @sh.itjust.works nanoUFO @sh.itjust.works 8mo ago

Stardew Valley is basically the same game 8 years later

www.polygon.com Stardew Valley is basically the same game 8 years later

There’s a reason why people still play this cozy farming sim, and it’s not just because of all the updates

23 comments

Ya know what other game is basically the same game 8 years later? Pretty much all of them. Games almost never just up and fundamentally change their core design after release. Why would a dev do that, when they can just make a new game?

What a weird article title.
- Title now shows as "In 8 years, Stardew Valley never lost sight of its core philosophy" for me.
  
  People don't really like to read the articles before commenting, huh.
  
  Knowing Stardew was such a beloved game, I knew I had to get context before judging the author because it could be read both ways.
  
  People who assume games not changing = criticism are telling us more about their own uncharitable view of others than anything else.
  
  EDIT: That said, if I were to offer criticism, I feel like the author gives too much credit to Stardew as though it invented or pioneered the tight gameplay loop: perhaps at least some mention could have been made to Harvest Moon, the game from which Stardew borrows - and perfects - most of its major systems.
  
  Also to be fair, it doesn't go anywhere with that thought that Stardew hasn't changed. Felt a little low-effort, like a retrospective on Stardew that just basically listed what people liked about it.
- No Man's Sky on the other hand
  
  Well, that one wasn't really much of a game at the release. More like a tech demo that they somehow transformed into a game later.
- Then you get shit like Stellaris that fundamentally changed their game at least two times. It's not even close to the game I originally bought, and I say that with mixed feelings.
  
  Stardew is in a good place, it doesn't need to change. If you want Stardew-but-not then play something else, plenty of good games. Slime Rancher, Core Keeper, Sun Haven...
  
  You can always go back to the old versions
"Minecraft is basically the same game 15 years later."

Yes and no. But mostly no.
- Minecraft is a wildly different game from what they released. The point of this article is that despite 8 years of regular updates, the core experience of playing Stardew Valley hasn't changed. I wish that were true of Minecraft.
"More than 38 years later, Super Mario Bros. is basically the same game it was at launch back in 1985. Will it make it to 40? Some aren't so sure, find out why!"
I really don't want to read this based on the headline and I don't want to subject anyone else to such a dumb sounding fate, but if anyone already has read it could you tell me where they were trying to go with this one?
That's... What I expect.

I really don't like when my games change so much over time that they're not even the same game anymore. I got the old game. I want the old game. If I wanted a new game, I'd get a new game.
I mean its a game, and not a game as a service.
It is strange. I tried it once and it felt incredibly stressful between the passing out mechanic, the questions demanding I introduce myself to every single person in the whole village within the first week,... yet people keep describing it as relaxing.
Also Polygon: water... is wet.

23 comments