Agreed. I like a few Office episodes, but I never really got into it. I'm also not a fan of self-deprecating humor, despite making a lot of self-deprecating jokes myself.
I watched all of The Office, but I had to keep actively reminding myself that those situations aren't real and that they're paid actors who are expecting everything that's happening, in order not to wince my face inside out.
I used to love sitcoms (Seinfeld, King of Queens, IT Crowd, etc), but I guess it's just not what I'm looking for anymore. If I want comedy, I usually go with stand-up these days.
Awkwardness is incredibly cheap to film and turn around into content. Less that you find it entertaining and more that you'll fixate on it as a clip in a long line of similar looking content. HBO / Discovery Channel love this kind of low-rent reality TV, because it gets people into watching the first episode purely on shock value. Also great for getting the name recognition of the show up among the critically lucrative "I'm too mature for cartoons but not mature enough to watch normal TV" 13-21 demographic.
Literally the only thing that matters is whether your cursor hovers over it or your scroll pauses for a second as you pass over it. The Algorithm will flag this as "We have your attention" and feed you an increasing quantity of the slop until you give in or you stop using whatever media service is delivering it.
I am the same way.
My husband loves I Think You Should Leave. I cannot stand how horrible and awkward it is. Like its not just not funny it's actively uncomfortable to watch. Which makes it even funnier to him >.>
"Real" awkwardness is usually coming at someone's expense. I don't enjoy that. The same way true sadness is usually at someone's expense.
But if it's part of a story, fine. I'll watch a sad movie or a show that has awkward moments. Those very real feelings explored in a fun way that hurts no one can be a good time. Just like no one really enjoys being genuinely scared, but a scary movie can trigger that emotion in a safe and fun way.