o7___o7 @ o7___o7 @awful.systems

[redacted] enthusiast, robot combat enjoyer, distressingly Appalachian, fat

---

Read more

Posts

11

Comments

1,115

Joined

2 yr. ago

Not sure, but it tracks, doesn't it?

I'm not sure, alas. I'm only a hobbyist. It seems that improved brushless motors is a direct follow-on of the mass production of high-strength rare earth magnets, the motors being my main point of contact. (you can also draw a straight line from this to the rapid development of drones and quadcopters when combined with high capacity batteries, as you pointed out. )

In my experience, pinning down exact comparisons between brushed and brushless motors is a source of frustration since brushless torque curves behave counterintuitively at low speeds, e.g. the second chart you see here:

https://www.fingertechrobotics.com/brushless-torque.php

That behavior is why you can't find a torque vs current draw curve for brushless motors. You can get an estimate based on kV values, but again, it is very speed dependent.

In terms of practical experience, and for speed ranges that you'll see IRL, brushless tends to give you substantially more torque per unit mass while running quietly and with higher efficiency to boot.

I see it on my current bookshelf project, and I'm cheap so my tools are low-end stuff I could scrounge or find on sale. My old-school brushed Black and Decker 18v drill chugs when drilling holes in the old recycled hardwood we're using for the project, wheras the brushless Ryobi 18v cuts through like it's nothing.

Based on what I've seen in my fighting bots, a drop-in replacement would get you get roughly a 50% boost in torque for a similar weight of motor at the speeds concerned, unless you wanted a low speed brawler and didn't want to gear the motor up much, in which case stick with brushed.

Sorry to carry on, it's a whole thing!

"vangaurdist libertarians" is so cursed

IMO, this grift is enabled by the miniaturization of brushless motors. It's been a bit of an underreported revolution, but the improvements are super obvious for anyone who has handled power tools in over the last 10 years; it's also a big deal for combat robots. You just get so much more power per kilogram of motor. These guys are lazy, so they didn't think to consider the wear from that kind of loading in their designs.

So the grifters just CAD up a believable people-shaped chassis, plonk in these new ittybitty motors, warm-over 20 year old dynamic stability research, have a few guys dance around in knitted gimp suits for the camera, and voila, they can vacuum up money from scifi-pilled rubes for years before vanishing.

Edit: also I can promote my niche hobby horse here: I maintain that Tombstone from the Battlebots tv series is the ultimate answer to these things (as well as skeleton hordes and zombie mobs).

Get their asses

A bit of uplifting news:

id software is now a union shop

https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/id-software-devs-form-wall-to-wall-union-with-165-workers-at-doom-studio-the-latest-to-vote-in-favour

Nothing makes you grounded than stuffing Land in a locker.

He's become the Linus Pauling of video games.

favorite one so far! It's like graduate-level 1-900 Hotdog

That's one Lemurian time demon for each side of the Time Cube.

They somehow misused every word in that sentence.

Absolutely savage 10/10 no notes

We lost a grant because of one of these shit emitters. I hate it.

I get what you're saying.

I hate when they make us untangle these linguistic knots. I think this is a motte-and-bailey¹ situation, like how the oppo respond to AI (LLM) criticism by implying we don't like AI (ML i.e. the old thing that works).

They likewise want datacenters (Big Hot Steaming Shitbox of GPUs...IN SPACE) not datacenters (radiation hardened, multiply-redundant, low-power industrial CPU clusters...IN SPACE)

¹ ugh sorry having a brain fart and cant think of a better term

Edit: I am reliably informed that I let one go over my head. Apologies!

In my defense, I would be entirely unsurprised if you turned out to be an expert in this stuff lol

Yes i know the kid in the omelas hole gets tortured each time i use the woe engine to generate an email. Is that bad?

In the land of the blind the one-eyed man will make a killling as an independent contractor cleaning up after this disaster concludes.

Nazi entanglements

That's why none of the quantum computers work

You flippin nailed the pronunciation

The one thing all of these people have in common is that they are miserable