Businesses still don’t know what an ‘AI agent’ is and they don’t really want one
Businesses still don’t know what an ‘AI agent’ is and they don’t really want one
What is an “AI agent,” anyway? We could concoct a reasonable definition — say, you tell it in natural language what you want and it goes out and does it for you. But that doesn’t describe the thing…
On the subject of AI agents, I saw a baffling commercial (or well half saw it several times) where they where trying to sell I think AI powered phones where they had the revolutionary AI agent idea of randomly feeling like you should meet up with friends, then just go to your friends and tell your phone that it should reschedule everything they had planned for a day later. Which baffled me in various ways, as mentioning this to your phone doesn't do anything, you can't reschedule without input from other people. Sure I might not want to go to my doc appointment today, but I can't just tell my phone 'hey tell my doc I will do it tomorrow not today'. And this is ignoring the fact that with AI reliability you need to actually check they did it correctly. It might have forgotten the order of the days, I mean it is a technology that already has failed on the most basic task. Just a very strange commercial, disconnected from how modern agendas and time works.
Why? Per the poll: “a lack of reliability.” The things being sold as “agents” don’t … work.
Vendors insist that the users are just holding the agents wrong. Per Bret Taylor of Sierra (and OpenAI):
Accept that it is imperfect. Rather than say, “Will AI do something wrong”, say, “When it does something wrong, what are the operational mitigations that we’ve put in place to deal with it?”
I think this illustrates the situation of the LLM market pretty well, not just at a shallow level of the base incentives of the parties at play, but also at a deeper level, showing the general lack of humanity and toleration of dogshit exhibited by the AI companies that they are trying to brainwash everyone with.
It's not unlike medical supplements before they got pushed away from real drugs and had all the markings on them about being just supplements rather than panaceas..
ATTENTION: LLM is not a real worker. Consult a competent manager before firing everyone around you.
Snake oil won't be a miscomparison on all points.
If a human employee makes a mistake, I can find out why, and correct the process used by the employee.
If an AI makes a mistake, I (currently) cannot see how it came to the result, nor can I correct it to not take that action again.