At the end of the day what matters is if it's good, but this looks bad. Everything about it feels like it's desperately trying to be whimsical but it's all forced and flat.
This brings up a good point actually. How are we feeling about Depp's Willy Wonka almost 20 years later? People hated it when it first came out but I've heard more positive things in recent years. Allegedly it's actually closer to the books than the Wilder version. But I've never read the book.
Timothee Chalamet just doesn't seem like the right fit for this role. He's just not selling it for me. Maybe it's because I've watched Dune too many times.
His performance just doesn't have whimsy in it. You can tell he's trying but it feels really forced. Wonka needs an exceptional performance, not just a big name.