Soy milk
Soy milk
Hi, every morning I have breakfast with unsweetened soy milk. My cats kill me if they can't empty my bowl, but because I add stuff like raisins which include sugar, I give them some plain soy milk instead. The vet said it's "probably fine", but I want to know for certain. Does anyone know for certain soy milk is or isn't bad for cats? Thanks!
In short soy isn't great for cats, but just giving them a bit of soy milk won't be harmful.
https://bedforpetprague.org/tpost/fxoxsd4211-why-soy-is-not-the-best-choice-for-cats
Wow, this is exactly the answer I was hoping for, thank you.
I had vegan friends who fed their cat vegan food. I'm a vegan too, but humans are omnivores, cats are carnivores. Feeding cats vegan food is bad in my opinion, I see it as animal abuse. It comes with a lot of health risks which are similar to what I read in the articles you posted. It all makes sense.
From now on, they will get a little bit of unsweetened soy milk once in a while, not every day. (I have to find a middle ground, otherwise they will kick me out)
Thanks! I really appreciate it :)
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15141877/
Also, daring to doubt your vet and ask the internet for opinions. Normally it's the other way around.
All I know for certain is that unsweetened is a lot better than regular. The added sugars and high calorie count is not good for cats.
Yeah, sugar is a big no no for cats. I'm making sure they won't get any. Same with salt.
I follow the advice of the vet, but the vet said they didn't know for certain. I'd rather have a specialist day they don't know something than make something up. So that's why I ask the internet. I prefer the vet's advice over random internet people but I got replies backed by sources so I'm happy.
Thank you for your reply, I really appreciate it :)
Hey, I’m a specialist- but not in cats.
But I got curious and looked it up, from what I’m seeing, small amounts as a treat are “probably” fine- the top hits note that cats may have difficulty digesting the plant protein in soy milk.
This would likely be more problematic if they have large amounts. (Also it does some weird stuff to their hormones so it’s probably best to keep it as “occasional”)
Your vet is likely seeing the same things and assuming it’s not massive amounts and “probably fine” is a reasonable answer.
Just keep an eye on them. If they start having digestive problems, maybe try stopping for a while and then smaller amounts.
its probably not—they are cats and designed to eat small animals, not heavily processed plant products. They probably love it because they are mammals and we all instinctually crave protein juice.
Have you tried offering them any of the milk products specifically designed for cats? I've seen a powdered goat milk with added probiotics at my local pet store, there's formula replacement for nursing kittens, and at least one other that I've seen.
Edit: Chewy seems to have quite a few "milk" products that are intended for cats: https://www.chewy.com/s?query=Milk&rh=PetType%3ACat
Your camera is so clear i thought it was AI for a second
Yeah I love it! It's a Oneplus 9pro, with Hasselblad firmware and filters. Amazing photos, every time!
Had that phone as well, only just replaced it after 4 years. Probably could have kept going but I wanted to spoil myself a bit and now I have a backup phone.
Started with OP 5, then 9, now the 13. Both the 5 and the 9 lasted 4 years with no issues.
pro tip—you can clean the lenses on your phone’s camera.
Ah yes, as we all know every Lemmy user is also a moonlighting cat nutritionist. Glad you came and asked here, your vet probably doesn't know what they're talking about!
I mean, there's a chance someone knows, right? We don't all have to.
How do you differentiate between the countless anonymous users who know for certain one way or another? And why would you trust their opinion over that of your vet?
Edit: Stop booing me, I'm right.
how about oat milk instead for the kitties (i personally like it better then soy milk anyway)
https://www.catster.com/nutrition/can-cats-drink-oat-milk/
Cats can have oat milk and it’s generally safe for them to drink
I just gave them some of mine. Since I'm a vegan, I need a replacement for regular milk. Only soy milk is a real substitute as it's the only plant based milk with protein, all the others are basically tasty water nutrician wise, plus whatever vitamins they added. For my cats, I think it's better to just buy something made for cats instead.
Pea milk has a similar amount of protein to soya and dairy. It doesn't have the beany flavour of soya (it's the closest to dairy in terms of flavour IMHO) and works well in hot drinks.
I have no idea if it's safe for cats though; it's typically made from yellow split peas.
No milk is good for cats.
They cannot digest it properly.
There is no milk in soy milk.
They cannot digest milk for the same reason as humans that are lactose intolerant. Non-dairy milk is a whole other thing, with their own concerns for health effects on cats.
I know cats are lactose intolerant, yes. That's why we're talking about soy milk instead. Thanks anyway.