Four Democrats Pass Bill Making It Harder for Married Women to Vote
Four Democrats Pass Bill Making It Harder for Married Women to Vote
You're viewing a single thread.
You can currently vote in the US without ID?
I don't understand what the controversy is, providing ID along with your voting card seems normal to me.
What am I missing? I scimmed the article.
We make people pay to get an ID partially because it's outsourced in many states to private companies.
I live in Canada, I can vote using my free government issued healthcard or I can bring a friend to vouch for me, or i can bring a student id and a bill. While most people probably vote with their drivers license or photo ID this enables people who are homeless, very old, or in my case in 2021, just moved. (Here's what's needed for the curious). You'll notice in that link there are special exemptions for people who live in long term care homes, for whom it is much more common to have no form of id.
People who don't have easy access to id are societies most vulnerable people and I think it is especially important that they have access to voting.
America does not have a free form of id (in most states anyway) and does not allow someone to vouch as a form of identification.
I'm Swedish. Don't know if someone can vouch for me. Never tried. Pretty sure I need an ID.
Everyone (18+) get a voting card in their mail sent to their adress. You bring the voting card and ID, like passport or drivers license. Someone ticks your name off a list and you can vote. (No registrering to vote or anything)
ID isn't free, but a passport costs like $40-50.
You can also get a national ID card. But that's even more expensive and I still don't quite understand why you would want one rather than just getting a passport.
I'm Estonian, we also have ID requirements, and an ID card is cheap. Passports aren't expensive either, but ID cards are more useful in day to day life.
The US is fucked. There's no standardized photo ID that everyone has to have. People only get passports for travel and the country is literally so huge and diverse you can travel more than most people have money to and see many different environments without leaving it. I reckon you could spend a year in NYC alone and not see everything there is to see. In 2006, 20% of Americans had passports, in 2011 it was 37%.
The most common form of photo ID to have is the driver's license. But some people don't get one. People also have social security cards, almost everyone has one, but that's not a photo ID.
Luckily they now have something called a passport card (pretty much just an ID card but allows travel to like Canada and Mexico I think?), that only costs 30 bucks to get. The actual book form of passport is 130 for application, and if you're an adult and it's your first passport, there's a 35 dollar acceptance fee, which all together is actually too much for some people.
They also have free voter ID cards which are nowhere close to free.
There's just a lot of bureaucratic inefficiency in the whole ID system in the US. It's fucked. If you're poor and can't get time off work to get a cheap form of ID, you might be fucked. If you don't have transport, you might be fucked.
Really, they should fix all this first and THEN mandate photo ID for voting. Right now it disproportionately affects people who have a hard time getting a photo ID, i.e poor people. Then there's the whole single voting day for in-person voting. It also disproportionately affects the working class - people who might have a hard time getting time off work. Wait, why is this an issue, your employer is legally mandated to give you time off to vote? Because in red states, in areas that vote blue, they only put one voting station for a whooooole bunch of people so you'd have to drive a long distance AND wait a long time in line. AND it's only 1-4 hours depending on state AND not all states have these laws.
The whole country is rigged to not let poor people to vote as easily as the wealthy, unfortunately.
I've spent quite some time in the US. I'm well aware of their bureaucracy. Maybe I just have a different opinion than others. I understand it causes some issues for some, but you can get a copy, or amend your US birth certificate for $50 using their own Government website. It's really not that difficult.
The fact you need to prove citizenship to register to vote is the least of their election problems.
The fact you need to prove citizenship to register to vote is the least of their election problems.
Is it? Potentially millions of citizens can't vote. There's exactly one party pushing for voter ID laws and it's not the one that young people without driver's licenses would likely vote for.
Yes... the electoral college is a much bigger issue. Senators each represent vastly different amount of people, yet their voting power are equal.
Two senators from California, representing 39 million people. Have no more say than two senators from Idaho representing 2 million people.
So 39 million people get 2 votes in the senate. And 2 million people also get 2 votes in the senate.
Democrats have had total power under Biden for 2 years. Did they make it any easier to vote? So you can say that only Republicans want "voter ID laws" but neither party gives a fuck about creating a functional system.
If they cared at all. They'd make sure every citizen is automatically registered. And there wouldn't even be a need for what they're pushing now.
Cool, never seen someone be vouch for, but as stated, that person vouching for you needs ID.
I understand that it's difficult for someone that is homeless to vote. The way we "solved" that here, is by doing everything we can to ensure that homeless people can be taken care of and have some kind of home, e.g. A room. And if all else fails, you can at least register with the government and they will make sure you have a place to receive mail. Meaning you will still get your voting card. You still need an ID, or have someone vouch for you, which could be difficult for a homeless person. But let's be real. Voting is going to be the least of their problems.
I agree. All citizens of legal age deserve to vote.
You can vote in a lot of countries without ID dude.
A birth certificate is a static document. In my case it was issued 47 fckn years ago. Why should i pay to update a half century document to match my current legal ID (passport, license , etc) I shouldn't and it's ridiculous
A friend changed her surname after being adopted by her stepfather. She's fucked by this as well. Anyone who's ever changed a stupid name, broken from a bad parent, been adopted, anglicised, or even had a fat fingered nurse typo is now fucked....because idiots are hysterical over 0.6% of the population.
Oh hey, that's me! Nurse swapped my vowels around. Literally hasn't been an issue for 37 years and now, it just might be.
Could you name these "a lot of countries"? Since it's a lot of them, shouldn't be too difficult to mention 20 right?
They say it's to prove citizenship, a passport is proof of citizenship isn't it? So that is enough no?
You can vote in all Canadian Elections without an id.
Wow... 4 countries + various US states doesn't require ID. Yeah, that's truly "A lot" of countries, dude.
You know how you keep saying "well we do this in my country so it's normal"
That shit cuts both ways dude...and I'm in Australia
If you want to paraphrase me, at least do it correctly, "Well, we do this in MOST countries, so it's normal" And yes, that is the definition of normal. It's normal because it's the norm. You guys are the exception. Not the other way around.
You said ID isn't required in "a lot of countries", and then you provide a graph (without a verifiable source) where the number of countries you don't need ID to vote in, can be counted on a single hand.
You know, you had a chance to learn about how other countries do things. Instead you chose to be a self righteous butt. Shame.
I mean that's the US in a nutshell tbh
Dude says they're Swedish though. But they did apparently spend a lot of time in the US......
Here in America we have a term for blaming Americans for non-Americans acting entitled, it's called 'Thanks Obama'
I know how Australia does things. You still need to prove your identity when you enrol to vote. If you don't have any of the proof they require, you can have a mate that is enrolled vouch that you are you along with your name and address.
The difference is that Australia is capable of keeping track of their citizens and are willing to verify your eligibility for you.
did....did you just literally explain how Australian enrollment and voting works to an australian who has been voting for 30 years
From vote.nz
You don’t need to take your driver licence, your passport, or anything else with you to a voting place. No ID is required.
Your EasyVote card, if you have one, will make voting faster – but you can vote without it.
When you go to vote, you’re either marked off the printed roll at the voting place, or your details are recorded. During the official count, we compare all the rolls from all the voting places in each electorate to make sure everyone has only voted once.
So you don't require ID, but you get sent an easy vote card, to speed up the process when you go to vote. It is super quick though, usually less than 5 minutes to vote usually.
yah in AU you go to a polling place in your LGA, and they check off your name / enrolled address on big ol' paper-filled binders listing everyone eligible to vote in that area. Then they validate the voting slips they give you and direct you to the booth.
Imagine a woman being born a Smith. She marries a Jones and changes her name and license. Her birth certificate is still Smith. She will be required to have the same name on her BC and License. She will have to choose and change one of them at her expense.
I don't quite follow the last part. "She will have to choose and change one of them at her expense"
Obviously you need to update your license if you change your name.
So she can update her BC to match her new name? Or is that impossible, thus making her unable to vote because of it.
I think many states require you already to provide an ID to vote. ID/Drivers license aren’t free.
I believe what they passed now, the SAVE Act, results in additional identification like a Birth Certificate or Passport. You have to prove citizenship in some manner. If you got married your last name won’t match your birth certificate, I’ve read of that being used as an example for reason to deny voting access.
I personally feel this is a waste of time and money to implement and will just be used for voter suppression.
Among the most notable changes outlined in the bill is the requirement to prove U.S. citizenship before registering to vote. Acceptable documents will include a birth certificate, U.S. passport, naturalization paperwork and certain versions of the Real ID that indicate citizenship.
(https://www.npr.org/2024/10/11/nx-s1-5147732/voter-fraud-explainer)