Honestly I kinda feel like an annular eclipse is prettier, but I'm still excited just for the rarity of the experience.
And who am I kidding? How often do annular eclipses happen either? I'm happy that EITHER happen near me lol
Edit 3 weeks later, after the eclipse:
I take it all back - the difference between a sliver of visible sun, and totality, is worlds apart. It's a totally different beast. It's in a different league. It doesn't seem like a big deal on camera, but in person it's incomparable.
I traveled to see the annular eclipse in October, and I'm traveling to the path of the total eclipse next month. I'm sure they both will be amazing experiences. My last total eclipse is decades ago.
According to Wikipedia, and data for the last century, there were 73 annular and 71 total eclipses, which is pretty close to the same. List of 20th century eclipses. Now, I haven't checked to see if there are more of one than the other in the eclipse cycle, but given the difference of 2 over a century and the cycle taking 18 years, it can't be more than one.
But see them while you can. In the distant future, there won't be any total eclipses.
For a total, it's fine as long as you ONLY look during actual totality. Once you see the Bailey's Beads (little diamonds at the edge), you need to put on your glasses.