I can't say I love either but I've tried a bunch of options and they were the best for me. Plus development has picked up on both recently so I hope they get polished up.
IIRC, the primary (and maybe only?) dev for k-9 mail on Android was hired by the Thunderbird team, and eventually, k-9 will get rebranded as a mobile version of Thunderbird (presumably with eventual setting sync capabilities and feature parity and such).
Yes, that is a large part of what I meant by "development has picked up". IIUC there are now multiple full-time devs on K9 (which I guess will be called Thunderbird Mobile or something eventually)
Generally I use Thunderbird since it's cross platform and consistent, though recently I've been trying out Geary and it's not bad, but definitely is a bit too basic for me. For example, it's not super obvious how to mark all messages in a folder as read - and when doing so in another client, I was stuck with an inconsistent unread counter.
So I'll probably just end up on good ole Thunderbird again.
On Android I just use the Gmail app, but I'll be looking to see how the new Thunderbird/K-9 update goes.
Same here. I am eager to test the new Thunderbird/K-9 update, but I believe I will stick with Thunderbird and FairEmail. Just because they are both exactly what I need.
I think claws on linux is fantastic. It's not packed with features, but it has everything I need and is very straightforward to configure and use once you've got your accounts connected. My work uses office365 for our emails which gave me a lot of trouble setting up, but I found a FOSS program called davmail which allows those accounts to be compatible with all email clients.
Normally I just use Gmail's web client, but maybe I should give Thunderbird a go. Last time I tried it, I felt like a second class citizen because everything was working through SMTP and IMAP. Generic protocols inevitably lose some functionality.
Looks like I'm going back to the web client. Thunderbird kept crashing my computer because it wants to download all of my hundreds of thousands of messages.