I always felt like this game was a response to the lackluster feedback for Final Fantasy 8. "Oh, you don't want it to be too realistic or gritty or whatever?! Time for wacky fantasy everything!"
I know my circle of friends was disappointed in 8, but 9 didn't even ping their radars.
I never finished 8 or 9, but it wasn't the setting or character design, I just didn't care about the characters the same way I used to. Cloud, Tifa and Aeris were instantly my posse. Locke and Terra were a wonderful mix of sorrow and compassion set against the backdrop of a ruthless and intriguing empire.
The later games never connected with my emotions in the same way and, eventually, I just stopped caring.
FF8 wasn’t bad because of the gritty sci-fi setting. It was bad because of the terrible teen angsty emo writing. The problem with all the FFs after 7 is just the bad writing. It’s a problem lot’s of modern Japanese media has. Way too much exposition and info dumping bull shit with cringe inducing dialogues clearly inspired by shonen manga these otaku writers grew up with. It’s like these Japanese writers don’t know how normal people, who aren’t manga obsessed geeks, communicate with each other.
Agreed, I remember feeling like 9 was a good move and bring excited to dig into something more like FF2/3 (US), but it wasn't what I was hoping for at all.
Dang I love 8 and 9. 8 definitely feels unfinished, but there are story moments that stick with me more from that game than almost any other. I played through all of the games in order so 9 was like a return to form for me. The first 6 games are much more of a fantasy setting so while I enjoy 7 and 8 it was nice to go back to the main setting of the series. I'm on X-2 right now so I cant comment on the later games.
I loved 9 and didn't finish 8, but i grew up playing the first. You are right, though, I barely remember the story, but as soon as I saw this picture i remembered every characters name and abilities except the red haired guy. I can't seem to remember anything about him.
I definitely got further into 9 than 8, but don't know that I ever met the entire cast. The only name I remember for sure is Vivi. Is the main guy Zidane, maybe?
I remember being so excited for 9, thinking it would take me back to 3, which was my rpg touchstone. I tried to really sell myself on it, but ultimately lost interest. I'd love to go back and try it again at some point and see how I feel.