I don't wear makeup often and I can't say I've tried many above average quality makeup removers.
But as far as my experience goes, with average products, yes. You will wake up next day with a smear around your eyes if you weren't extra thorough with the cleanup. "One step" doesn't cut it, you need to put some dedication there
Yeah, any product claiming that is a product I don't buy.
Cold cream is the only thing I've found that really will remove all of my makeup, and it still requires patiently rubbing it into my eye makeup and wiping carefully (especially the eyelashes!) several times to be sure it's fully gone. And then comes cleanser and the rest of my skincare.
This is a legit question; I have not worn makeup since 2000 or so so I’m outdated on makeup tech, but baby oil was good enough to remove everything without being painful, I assume it’s bad for your eyes in some way, or something like that…