What's your favourite it's all in the gameplay game?

The Dwarf Fortress model. Losing is fun!

So like, yes, I totally agree.

I want to take a second to tell a story though, about the graphics in this game. I hope to explain why this game actually has the best graphics ever.

Context for some folks: the game is entirely rendered using ASCII characters (for the purpose of this story. I know, I'm leaving out detail, it's okay). So the goblins in Dwarf Fortress look roughly like this

g

A dog looks like this

d

And a dragon looks like this

D

Learning to play Dwarf Fortress can be tough at first because there's a soup of letters and other typing characters on the screen and your brain needs to convert that into a scene that makes sense. But here's the thing ... eventually that's exactly what your brain does! You stop seeing the semicolons and hyphens, the letters and the strange formatting characters like "╥". You start to see rivers and grass, tiny people working hard, a bustling metropolis, an invading horde.

And the creator of this game hasn't simply cut corners on making the game look good by using ASCII tilesets. The grass (made of commas or single quotes) sways in the breeze. Running water shimmers. Cherry trees gently rain cherry blossom petals during certain seasons. There's actually a ton of little details there for your brain to pick up and immediately upscale into high def for you. It's delightful. And sometimes terrifying.

Sometimes something new will happen. A creature you've never seen before will approach your little community. It will be represented by some letter and your brain will render that for you in the way it has been taught to do. Your eyes see a d and you see a dog. Your eyes see a D and you see a dragon. It's bigger than a dog. Most things are, no big deal. But you've been deceived.

You watch as a band of dwarfs approach the dragon. The creature is quite still, right next to the round trunk of a tree that looks like this O. The brave warriors are still far from the creature. You've built whole dinning halls, with wooden chairs and stone mugs and carvings decorating the walls, that could fit within the space separating the warriors from the capital D dragon. One canny dwarf let's loose an arrow at the beast. It zips through the air like this -

As it approaches the Dragon, which is surely just to Iike a dog but a bit larger and green right, time begins the slow. It ticks. And ticks. And hell is unleashed. Flames jet from the Dragon. Unending flames pouring like red ink in billows that quickly fill the vast space and enrobe the dwarven warriors in a superheated death that pushes in and flows past and even through the band until flickering flames fill virtually all space to one side of a capital D that you will never, ever, mistake the size of again.

My scalp tingled and it felt like my skull was over heating when my brain spontaneously supplied all the extra graphical details for that particular scene. I'll never forget it.

He said game, not crack sir.

Cackles in 5700 hours worth

Such a lousy multiplayer game though. It was designed to give the better player handicap so their lead only increased over time, since you were awarded with more lemmings for the next level if you won the previous one.

I always hated it as a kid. All hundred iterations of it, despite always playing with them a little.

Has been on my to-try list. The old one I mean, I don't have the new.

Been looking for a spiritual successor for 25 years but nothing scratches that itch.

With that said the game is widely unbalanced and full of totally broken strategies, which somehow doesn't make it less fun.

arcadey

Only from the perspective of Orbiter and Elite Dangerous maybe.

Games that maybe don't look the best or maybe older, but it doesn't matter because the gameplay runs deep

Another point for Nioh 2. Still the single best souls-like for pure gameplay if you give it the chance.

Sekiro for me, for similar reasons.