You're viewing a single thread.
There is no ethical consumption under capitalism.
"Buying meat is unethical because of how the animals are treated" ~ sent from my iPhone made by child slave labor
I'm not saying veganism is bad. What I am saying is that people who think veganism is a moral high ground are wrong. I also think that veganism is a luxury to be even able to follow.
Edit after downvotes into the negative and shitty asshole responses:
Here comes the self-righteous assholes who don't want to have a discussion and instead throw around blame and shame at me. Congrats. Y'all are the reason people hate vegans which hurts your cause by pushing people away from reducing reliance on meat. Every downvote is proof that self-righteous vegans are assholes.The devil is in the details, but in most cases it's eating animal products that's the luxury.
https://www.veganeasy.org/discover/news/oxford-university-researchers-finds-vegan-diets-are-cheaper/
Nice cherry-picked argument there. Notice how the article doesn't link the study.
Doing my own analysis for myself, this is not the case.
You could have just googled the doctor's name and found the study yourself. Somehow I doubt 'your own analysis' is as unbiased as you think. https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1523119113
I shouldn't have to look up the study myself if an article is based on it. Also, that study you linked is not the one that the article mentions.
And yeah, the analysis is biased because it's literally for myself, where I live, and what I need. You think that's a gotcha?
Well in germany it's really easy to be vegan. Lots of affordable options
Congrats on that luxury being available to you
Funny thing is that Meat is waaay more expensive to produce then any Vegan alternative but why is Meat not seen as a luxury?
Because that's a short-sighted perspective. Production costs are not the same as consumer costs.
Yea meat is being heavily subsidised to bring the cost down, but in reality you pay with your tax money. Also plant based stuff is differently taxed (at least here in germany). Cow milk has a 7% tax and soy milk 19%. There is so much groing wrong because of lobbying by the meat companies.
Meat is just an extra costly step to produce the food we consume. Instead you could just skip that part and it would be less expensive.
There's so many other equally or even more important issues with how taxes are used, or misused, than just the meat industry.
Yes add animal cruelty to on top of that + health issues with meat consumption. Many good reasons to not eat meat and support that terrible buisiness.
There's a lot of issues that are much higher on my list of priorities than animal cruelty in the meat industry.
"Health issues with me at consumption" is a poor distillation of something that requires a lot more nuance.
Meat industry is also a big player in climate change. Another issue if you need more :) I don't really know what your priorities are but maybe this is important to you.
Well meat consumption is linked to many health issue, include the higher risk of cancer. But of course it also depends on the dosis but really not many people think about how much meat they consume.
You can be opposed to unethical treatment of animals and child slave labor. If someone tells me they are against slave labor, my response isn't ""buying products made by slaves is unethical" ~said by someone who eats factory farmed meat". It doesn't have to be one or the other.
I don't think people go vegan because they want a moral high ground, at least I know I didn't. People do it because they genuinely believe it's the right choice to make. And yes, having that choice is a luxury not afforded to everyone, but vegans are no more entitled than the people around them who also have the luxury of being able to choose not to support animal agriculture, but do so anyway.
You say people don't want to have a discussion while at the same time calling people who might actually engage in a discussion "self-righteous assholes". This leads me to believe you may not actually be looking for a good faith conversation.
The last part of my message was an edit after being downvoted to the negatives and other peoples very toxic responses.
Which response(s) came across as very toxic? I see six responses to your parent comment and they all seem quite civil.
Sorry, how is it a luxury? Vegetables, grains, and legumes are far cheaper and healthier sources of calories and nutrition than meat, despite the government subsidies. This perception that you should eat McDonalds and rotisserie chicken every day if you don’t have money to buy groceries is so strange to me.
This perception that you should eat McDonalds and rotisserie chicken every day if you don’t have money to buy groceries is so strange to me.
That's because no one here brought that up and you're using a straw man argument.
So in what way is it a luxury?
It's pretty ethical to grow and hunt your own food. Hunting even benefits the eco-system and animals haunted since the natural predators that used to keep deer, turkey, elk, and other game animals population in check are no longer prevalent.
Personally, I can agree in some circumstances. However, not everyone agrees with that and that is also fine.
Just don't try to shove your morals down my throat.
Lots of people don't agree, but we have data to support the benefits, and the legislation to ensure it is enforced. Yes, in an ideal world we'd all be vegans, and nature would balance itself. Maybe some day that will be the world we have, but it is not the world we have now.
However, not everyone agrees with that and that is also fine
It's even finer because in those situations those people would just die
Wut. Are you saying you're happy that people who disagree with killing animals themselves "would just die"?
Are you saying
Has anything truthful ever come after those words?
I was asking for clarification. Why are you implying I was trying to be dishonest?
Correct.