Skip Navigation

Amy Coney Barrett’s Call for a SCOTUS Ethics Code Comes With an Exasperating Rider

slate.com Amy Coney Barrett’s Call for a SCOTUS Ethics Code Comes With an Exasperating Rider

The Supreme Court remains the only court in the U.S. without a written code of conduct.

Amy Coney Barrett’s Call for a SCOTUS Ethics Code Comes With an Exasperating Rider

Justice Amy Coney Barrett recently became the second member of the Supreme Court, joining Justice Elena Kagan, to explicitly support the adoption of a SCOTUS ethics code. It would be a “good idea” to adopt a code, she told an audience on Monday at the University of Minnesota Law School, “particularly so that we can communicate to the public exactly what it is that we are doing in a clearer way than perhaps we have been able to do so far.” That was admirable candor, not least because it must have ruffled some feathers among the likely holdouts on the court.

But then Barrett continued with an assurance that there is “unanimity among all nine justices that we should and do hold ourselves to the highest ethical standards possible.” Who was she kidding? Perhaps she had to concede something like that as a matter of politesse, but anyone who has been paying attention knows that Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito have not been holding themselves to the “highest ethical standards possible.” At best, they have grudgingly adhered to the bare-minimum legal requirements of their job, while flouting anything resembling the highest possible standards. Alito has even bragged of his belief that no institution can hold the justices accountable.

5

You're viewing a single thread.

5 comments