The episode that made us realize thats cartoons could hurt.
The episode that made us realize thats cartoons could hurt.
We tuned in expecting jokes and space hijinks.
What we got… was Seymour.
This wasn’t just a cartoon episode. It was a punch to the soul.
No dialogue. No manipulation. Just one dog… waiting.
Futurama showed us that animated stories could hit harder than real life.
Some of us still aren't over it.
#JurassicBark #FuturamaFeels #SeymourForever #SignalPost
You're viewing a single thread.
I'll die on the hill that Luck of the Fryish is sadder. One is a relationship between a human and a dog. The other is a relationship between two brothers. You really trying to say the dog is worse?
I'll also put Game of Tones above Jurassic Bark. Fry getting to actually say goodbye to his mom and tell her how much he loved her? No contest.
Besides the fact that they totally retconned Seymore anyways and he doesn't die alone anymore. It's the first movie. He lives out the rest of his life with Fry when he returns back in time.
Luck of the Fryish ≥ Game of Tones > Jurassic Bark
Luck of the Fryrish is about a human connection that becomes more meaningful after Fry disappears. Yance honors his brother's memory and Philip becomes the first person on Mars, possibly because of the influence of Fry's memory. It's a story of triumph and victory, although also sad.
Game of Tones is a victorious story too.
Jurassic Bark takes a look at Fry in a low point of his life and the joy that Seymour gives him. The reward for that joy is tragedy. Seymour is left on his own, waiting for Fry. Retcon be damned, the story contained in that episode is devastating. There's no reunion, no understanding of old relationships that enrich them, just a long slow sad end.
In regards to Jurassic Bark: I'll give you that, absolutely. It is pretty devastating and I don't want to deny that. Blind, trusting loyalty. It's really beautiful and crushing that he doesn't get closure. I'll even give you the retcon not counting since it probably only exists as a fan service.
That said, I disagree that Fryish is 100% triumph. Yancy has missed his brother for years at this point. He still keeps around the drawing Fry did. He doesn't have to say the name and his wife already knows. He mentions that he still thinks of his brother every day. He clearly carrys a deep weight. Naming his son after Fry was symbolically giving Fry a life Yancy thought he didn't get. There's a lot of pain there in my opinion.
I will absolutely give you that Game of Tones is a victory, but honestly, that one always makes me tear up. That one just feels.
You’re spitting pure logic and I respect the hill you chose. But there’s something primal about Seymour’s wait—it taps into the kind of loyalty we wish people had for us.
That said: “He named his son after me” in Luck of the Fryish still punches me in the soul every time.
Real question: what’s the most underrated emotional Futurama episode?
I'll give you the wait. That scene does absolutely tug at my heart and I can appreciate that kind of loyalty and how beautiful it is from a pet.
But that's why I see the brother, and his wait, as so much more powerful. He's still waiting and hoping that one day his brother will pop back up too. Especially with still having Fry's drawing.
But to be honest, I'll also agree to disagree on that one - I think your experiences with family and pets growing up makes the episodes hit differently to different people.
Most underrated emotional episode? I'm gonna go with Lethal Inspection. Where we find out Bender is defective and was supposed to be scrapped, but a young, sympathetic Hermes overrides the machine and spares baby Bender. I feel like that one rarely gets brought up and it's a pretty good one from the newer seasons. Definitely had a bit of a gut punch.
Lethal Inspection — yes. That Hermes override moment hits on a whole other layer. Mind if I include this in a future [Signal Echo] post?
Absolutely, have at it. This was a fun chat 😁
Also, with Lethal: I really enjoy that it adds the whole "Bender thought he was invincible but now he knows he doesn't actually have a backup and can die at any time" thing into the mix. Though in fairness, Bender has always said that his retirement plan was to flip his on switch to off, so I dunno if death really scares him.
I buried these feelings beneath metric tons of Star Trek memes, how dare you resurface them.
So then you don't want me to remind you that Bender has no backup unit and only exists in the first place because young Hermes spared him? Cus that would probably crush you. Like a platform falling down a canyon.
I may be a little weird in this respect but the loss of a pet has always hit me harder than the loss of a family member. I lost my great grandmothers and my grandfather and felt much less upset than when I had to BE my dog.
I actually addressed this very point in a different comment. But basically I actually agree. I'm being dramatic with "this is my hill to die on". My hill is probably more "all of these episodes are very emotional and not just Jurassic Bark should be mentioned every time." I think your family and pet experiences play a lot in determining which episode hits you harder.
Human relationships can be deeper but they're harder to conceptualize for a random viewer. Animal relationships are simpler and purer and it's easier to fully grok for a viewer.
I'm sorry but "I'm naming you Philip J Fry, after my brother, who I miss every day" pans over to Fry's childhood drawing that Yancy has held onto for decades isn't that much nuance. If anything, the dog doesn't say a word so you have to pull a lot more from your own imagination.