I compared Google and Samsung’s AI photo-editing tools. It’s not even close.
I compared Google and Samsung’s AI photo-editing tools. It’s not even close.
Google and Samsung both have their own versions of an object removal tool. But which one works better? We found out.
cross-posted from: https://lemm.ee/post/30602302
Interesting comparison of the AI eraser functions on the Pixel versus the Galaxy.
You're viewing a single thread.
TL;DR: Samsung is better, according to the author.
Some questions remain though, as Google's Magic Eraser gives multiple options for object removal. Some are quite bad or blotchy, others are nearly seamless. Don't like any of the options it's provided, then ask it to try again. The author doesn't touch on this at all. Did they select the first option everytime? Was this the best of the options they were provided?
Better guess: they were incentivized to only delve as far as they did.
From the article:
Let’s first start by getting the facts out of the way — erasing objects won’t be perfect. In this comparison, we aren’t using the more advanced AI editing tools (Magic Editor for Google phones and Generative Edit for Samsung phones), just the basic object erasers. These tools work best on smaller objects rather than people right next to you or larger objects.
Yeah, to be fair, the naming isn't great and I can see why people get confused by it. Magic Edit is not Magic Eraser. Magic Edit uses GenAI and gives you multiple options to choose from, while Magic Eraser is not based on GenAI and will only give you the result and no options to choose from.