is federation as fucking terrible on mastodon like it is on lemmy?
so right now im having some pretty major annoyances with how federation is implemented by lemmy as a whole. defed makes it so you cant see whole threads, so looking at AMAs on lemmy.ml from hexbear are essentially useless unless you are viewing the main post, same with technical questions. which means lemmy cant replace reddit for a wide variety of uses. what i guess im asking is, can this be fixed, or is it innate to activitypub?
this is gonna be a huge problem as more and more instances are made. you could see someone make a question post but then you could create duplicate answers, wasting many people's time completely because you cant see each other. its also annoying as fuck that if i enjoy the community here, i have to keep making more and more accounts to access the fediverse as it inevitably becomes more fragmented. so in order to make sure that everyone sees everything youd have to keep creating accounts which is completely antithetical to the idea of the fediverse.
like i'd be ok with not being able to reply to certain instances, or choosing to block instances myself, but having that decision made for me is extremely lame. like if im in some instance talking about star trek or some shit, WHY does it fucking matter that im on a wrongthink instance so certain users cant see or reply to each others shit???
I can't even see all comments on lemmygrad threads from hexbear, even though I'm pretty sure we're as federated with them as possible because they're the only other people who aren't libs.
If I could at least log in on lemmygrad with my hexbear account then that would be more usable.
Or if the instance hosting the thread had final say on what's shown or not, regardless of the inter-site politics of who's federated with whom.
Or if the instance hosting the thread had final say on what's shown or not, regardless of the inter-site politics of who's federated with whom.
This seems like the obvious answer, and much simpler than how it actually works so I’m not sure why they didn’t do that in the first place. Whatever instance a thread is on controls it, that’s it.