Skip Navigation

Do any hardened Linux distributions exist?

For example, ones that implement these guidelines? https://madaidans-insecurities.github.io/guides/linux-hardening.html

Alternatively, packages for Fedora that would set this up automatically

33

You're viewing a single thread.

33 comments
  • I would look into Gentoo's Hardened + SELinux profile if you want good security in a standard system, but as others have mentioned QubesOS is probably the most secure option OOTB (but it is very limiting). SELinux is pretty difficult to use but it's really effective, and there is good information about it on the Gentoo wiki. Not sure what exactly goes into their hardened profile but I know it implements at least some of the suggestions listed on that site (like hardened compilation flags). Also it's probably more vulnerable to 0-day attacks than Qubes, since it uses up-to-date software. But it's really flexible, and learning SELinux is useful

    • You can even mix and match it H/SELinux with musl (and Clang, if you're up for some masochism and performance boost), though it does require patching sometimes. From my experience, you can find patches from Alpine's Aports and that should fix it ~90% of the time, but sometimes you'd need to write your own. Another tip in case you're interested in trying musl on Gentoo is that there's a compilation flag for large file support documented in Gentoo Wiki's musl development page which fixes compilation failures caused by calls to functions with names ending in 64 (e.g. fseek64). This is yet another massive source of compilation failure in musl. Lastly, you should mask musl versions ≥ 1.2.4 if you want to have any semblance of a * good time with it.

      • Oh good to know! Thanks for the tips. What do you like about musl over glibc?

        • To be honest, I only use it for fun. Unless you enjoy tinkering like I do, or you have really low RAM, there's no reason to use it over glibc. I'm aware that Madaidan also mentioned that it is more secure, but I'm not too knowledgeable on that so I can't really comment.

          • Ah gotcha, just asking because I've never used it before. Good to know that Gentoo supports hardening it

            • Gentoo lets you do basically whatever you want. The whole idea of it is that you make all the decisions in your system, as opposed to how most distros impose their developers' choices.

              • Yep! Gotta love the flexibility of it

                • Really fasttracked my Linux learning experience too. If you're starting out Linux and are predisposed to masochism like I am, using Gentoo as your first distro really catalysed my understanding of Linux (at the cost of a week's worth of crying and self-loathing lmao).

                  • Totally, props on taking it on as your first distro! Haha, yeah a week of pain sounds about right. My last Gentoo setup took an entire month (off and on), but I was doing something crazy (Qubes-like, every application in its own Gentoo VM, strict SELinux on host and guests)... ended up ditching that because I got comfortable enough with SELinux to write stronger policies for everything important, which is good enough for me.

                    I had the benefit of using other distros before trying Gentoo, so my first attempt at it wasn't so bad (but still took two full days). It's definitely taught me way more than any other distro, including Arch (although Arch was a very good stepping stone). I don't think I could go back to anything else at this point

                    • What a coincidence, I'm trying to learn SELinux too! Any tips?

                      • Awesome! Here are a few things that come to mind:


                        Make sure you have some aliases/functions for common operations:

                        • audit2allow -a to view audit violations (or -d for dmesg audits)
                          • also -r to add a requires statement for module construction
                        • restorecon -Rv to recursively apply file contexts from policy (or -FRv to also apply user context)
                        • rm -f /var/log/audit/audit.log.*; >/var/log/audit/audit.log to clear audit logs
                          • note: sometimes lots of logfiles (audit.log.1, etc.) collect, slowing down audit2allow
                        • chown -R user:user PATH; chcon -R -u user_u PATH to recursively change labels to user
                          • could be generalized for arbitrary Linux/SELinux users
                        • semanage fcontext -a -t TYPE PATH -s $SEUSER to add a custom file context to the policy
                          • e.g. semanage fcontext -a -t "user_secrets_t" "/home/[^/]+/.secrets(/.*)?" -s user_u
                          • I've had better luck with this approach than the standard method of creating a .fc file, but in any case a custom policy is needed to create custom types
                        • semanage fcontext -d PATH to remove a custom file context
                        • semanage fcontext -lC to list custom file contexts
                        • semodule -DB to rebuild policy with all dontaudit rules disabled
                          • often, something will not work, but audit2allow doesn't show anything
                        • semodule -B to rebuild policy (with dontaudit rules)
                        • semodule -i MODULE.pp to install a module
                        • semodule -r MODULE to remove a module

                        Also a few scripts for policy creation and management are essential. There are two basic approaches to policy creation: modules and policy modules.


                        Modules: can be used to modify AVC rules and are pretty simple

                        # a violation has occurred that you want to allow or dontaudit
                        echo "module my_allow 1.0;" > my_allow.te
                        audit2allow -ar >> my_allow.te
                        
                        # verify that my_allow.te has what you expect
                        cat my_allow.te
                        
                        # build and install the module (replace mcs with whatever policy you are using)
                        make -f /usr/share/selinux/mcs/include/Makefile my_allow.pp
                        semodule -i my_allow.pp
                        
                        # clear audit logs
                        rm -f /var/log/audit/audit.log.*; >/var/log/audit/audit.log
                        

                        Policy modules: can do anything, but are complicated, and the tools for creating them are mostly based on Red Hat.

                        Creating a new type:

                        # generate foo.fc, foo.if, and foo.te
                        sepolicy generate --newtype -t foo_var_lib_t -n foo
                        
                        # note: see sepolicy-generate(8); sepolicy generate only supports the following
                        #       type suffixes, but its output files can be adapted to your use case
                        # _tmp_t
                        # _unit_file_t
                        # _var_cache_t
                        # _var_lib_t
                        # _var_log_t
                        # _var_run_t
                        # _var_spool_t
                        # _port_t
                        
                        # modify the .fc file with the desired file contexts, for example (with s0 for mcs)
                        # /path/to/context/target	--	gen_context(system_u:object_r:type_t,s0)
                        #
                        # note: the "--" matches regular files, -d for directories, -c for character
                        #       devices, -l for symbolic links, -b for block devices, or can be omitted
                        #       to match anything. also, as mentioned before, I often have better luck
                        #       with `semanage fcontext`, especially for user directories
                        vi foo.fc
                        
                        # build and install the policy module
                        make -f /usr/share/selinux/mcs/include/Makefile foo.pp
                        semodule -i foo.pp
                        
                        # use restorecon to adjust the file contexts of any paths you have 
                        
                        # by default, all operations involving this type will be denied
                        # (and are sometimes not audited)
                        semodule -DB # --disable_dontaudit
                        # ... use the type, collect violations ...
                        audit2allow -ar >> foo.te
                        # if dontaudit is disabled, you'll likely have a lot things to remove from here
                        vi foo.te
                        
                        # ... repeat until rules regarding type are fully defined
                        

                        Creating a new application type:

                        # sepolicy-generate is made for Red Hat,
                        # but you can use --application to get started
                        
                        # creates a bunch of files that define bar_t and bar_exec_t
                        sepolicy generate --application -n bar [-u USER] CMD
                        
                        # remove the line making the app permissive (up to you, but
                        # I prefer using audit violations to define the permissions)
                        perl -i -00 -pe 's/^permissive bar_t;\n\n//g' bar.te
                        
                        # ensure that the file bar_exec_t file context points to the right bin:
                        vi bar.fc
                        
                        # build and install the policy module
                        make -f /usr/share/selinux/mcs/include/Makefile bar.pp
                        semodule -i bar.pp
                        
                        # ... use the application, update AVC rules, repeat ...
                        

                        If your target application is interpreted, you'll need to write a custom C program that launches the interpreter in a specific context, then write your policy around that application. For example, you should execv something like this: /usr/bin/runcon -u user_u -t my_script_t /bin/bash PROG.

33 comments