Yep this is the downside of being a discerning film lover with a friend group that watches movies together. I had this experience recently when we saw Longlegs (2024) in theaters. One friend LOVED it (he has notoriously bad taste), two friends thought it was decent, and I thought it was mediocre.
someone was hyped about beetlejuice 2 and i said i hadn't seen the first one so he put it on. it's a godawful dumpster fire of a movie but apparently im the only one who thinks so.