awesome old AI paper Artificial Intelligence Meets Natural Stupidity (PDF, 1976)

So many of the criticisms here survive essentially unchanged, fifty years later:

If he calls the main loop of his program "UNDERSTAND", he is (until proven innocent) merely begging the question. He may mislead a lot of people, most prominently himself, and enrage a lot of others.[…] If Quillian <1969> had called his program the "Teachable Language Node Net Intersection Finder", he would have saved us some reading. (Except for those of us fanatic about finding the part on teachability.)

2 评论

NIXON IS-A HITLER, indeed. Yes sir, we've come a long way since 1976.
^But ^not ⁱⁿ ^a ^good ^way.
So many of the criticisms here survive essentially unchanged, fifty years later:
If he calls the main loop of his program "UNDERSTAND", he is (until proven innocent) merely begging the question. He may mislead a lot of people, most prominently himself, and enrage a lot of others.[…] If Quillian <1969> had called his program the "Teachable Language Node Net Intersection Finder", he would have saved us some reading. (Except for those of us fanatic about finding the part on teachability.)