Trigger rumble for Xbox controller?

I have an Xbox elite series 2 and the trigger rumble used to work for Forza Horizon 6 when I used Bluetooth. The problem is that I recently upgraded my CPU and motherboard and no longer have built in WiFi/Bluetooth so now I have to play with a wire. I still get main body vibration but the triggers feel totally dead. If I have to get a WiFi card I will, but do you guys have any insight for anything I can try before that?